Frames serve as bridges between elite discourse about a problem or issue. A constructionist approach, the american journal of sociology, 951, pp. Gamson and kathryn eilene lasch center for research on social organization university of michigan paper prepared for the pinhas sapir international conference on development. Many studies focus on news media coverage in north america or europe. Type article authors g gamson, a modigliani date 1989 volume 95 issue 1 page start 1 page end 37 is part of journal title american journal of sociology. The role of interaction sequences and the timing of. New approaches to the analysis of mass media discourse and communication. Framing as media effects 103 framing as a theory of media effects by dietram a. The lens through which we receive these images is not neutral but evinces the power and point of view of the political and economic elites who operate and focus it. Media framing of hitlers early years, 192324 by katherine blunt 93 military capability, diplomatic efforts, influential relationships, and, in some cases, the illegality of his actions.
Discursive narratives about nuclear power in the aftermath. Upon identifying the different packages available in mass media, they are able to trace the frequency of each packages appearance over time and articulate the patterns in media discourse. The mass media have often been scrutinized for their traditional and narrow depictions of women and men, which emphasize the differences between what it means to be a woman and a man. For me, that captures the way meaning can be embedded across stories, media, and time. Gamson and modigliani 1989 put frames within larger containers that they call media packages. The analysis traces the careers of different interpretive packages on nuclear power.
For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription. Gamson and andre modigliani, media discourse and public. The manualholistic approach is essential for correct interpretation of framing devices. The overwhelming conclusion is that the media generally operate in ways that promote. It is difficult to find anyone who would claim that media discourse in the united states even remotely approaches this ideal. The end of framing as we know itand the future of media. If news media arent actively seeking out stories, they are often missed. Contemporary approaches to the study of education policy and discourse, guest edited by jessica nina lester, chad lochmiller, and rachael gabriel. New approaches to the analysis of mass media discourse and. We begin by arguing for changes in how communication scholars approach framing as a theoretical construct. One example found in gamson and modigliani 1989gamson, w. William gamson, a constructionist approach to mass media and public opinion, symbolic interaction 11 1988. In 1989, sociologist william gamson and social psychologist andre modigliani conducted an extensive media analysis on nuclear energy discourseover a 30year period, identifying six packages, defined as the metaphors, catchphrases, visual images, moral appeals, and other symbolic devices that characterizediscourse. And when looking at frames spread across discourse, rather than contained.
Media discourse is only one of several forms of public discourse, including expert discourse and policy maker discourse, among others. Yet these studies suffer from circular reasoning because they ignore the vast population of civil society organizations that fail to. Nuclear technologies raise social controversy, and the media are an. Movements and media as interacting systems william a. His recent work has dealt with media discourse on political issues and its relationship to public opinion. This paper explores their relationship by analyzing the discourse on nuclear power in four general audience media. In a later article, gamson and modigliani applied the same method to study the media discourse on the topic of nuclear power. Media images and the social construction of reality william a. Yet these studies suffer from circular reasoning because they ignore the vast population of civil society organizations that fail to breach the public. But media discourse is arguably most influential in terms of shaping public opinion gamson and modigliani 1989.
As an approach to media texts, framing seems to capture more of the network society castells, 2000 paradigm than the traditional senderreceiver, messageeffects model. New challenges for researching the structure of meaning in news brian baresch, shihhsien hsu and stephen d. Media coverage is theorized to both reflect and create public policy and public opinion. Mediated communication and commoditization of the female. Media discourse and public opinion are treated as two parallel systems of. We walk around with media generated images of the world, using them to construct meaning about political and social issues. Media discourse and public opinion are treated as two parallel systems of constructing meaning. William gamson and his colleagues have documente d extensively the careers of frames shaping media coverage of such domestic controversies as welfare, affirmative action, and nuclear power gamson and lasch, 1983. Gamson and kathryn eilene lasch center for research on social organization university of michigan paper prepared for the pinhas sapir international conference on. Media images and the social construction of reality. The political culture of social welfare policy william a. Scheufele research on framing is characterized by theoretical and empirical vagueness. Changing media depictions of welfare in the 20th century joya misra, university of massachusetts, amherst. Gamson boston college andre modigliani university of michigan media discourse and public opinion are treated as two parallel sys tems of constructing meaning.
He is an associate professor of sociology at the university of michigan, ann arbor. Gamson and andre modigliani, media discourse and public opinion on nuclear power. Health, education, and welfare, tel aviv university, israel, december, 1980. Reese starting in late 2010 and through the firstseveral months of 2011, a series of protests. A constructionist approach, american journal of sociology 95 1989. Go to previous content download this content share this content add this content to favorites go to next content. Toward a theory relating political discourse, media, and public opinion adam f. Their analysis of media discourse on nuclear power. Theory and typology 53 of selection, emphasis and exclusion by which symbolhandlers routinely organize discourse. Using media content analysis to understand the policy process nancy green saraisky. Gamson and modigliani 1989 assert that every policy issue has a culture.
Pdf media discourse and public opinion on nuclear power. Gamson and gadi wolfsfeld eses are offered concerning the ways in which social movements abstract. States even remotely approaches this ideal, gamson et al. Frames work as schemata of interpretation that enable individuals to locate, perceive, identify and label occurrences within their life space and the world at large.
This article provides an indepth examination of framing and positions the theory in the context of recent evolutions in media effects research. This paper explores their relationship by analyzing the discourse on nuclear power in four. According to gamson and modigliani 1989, media discourse is part of a process by which individuals construct meaning, and public opinion is part of the process by which journalists. These studies, for instance, have examined the kinds of frames that were used to depict nuclear energy in the us media e. Toward a theory relating political discourse, media, and. He is the author of numerous books and articles on political discourse, the mass media and social movements from as early as the 1960s. In 1989, sociologist william gamson and social psychologist andre modigliani conducted an extensive media analysis on nuclear energy discourseover a 30year period, identifying six packages, defined as the metaphors, catchphrases, visual images, moral appeals, and other symbolic devices that characterize discourse. A strategy for testing rival theories and conceptions of social life.
His recent work has dealt with media discourse on political issues and. Media content analysis can be an economical form of data collection, since much. Gamson boston college andre modigliani university of michigan media discourse and public opinion are treated as two parallel systems of constructing meaning. Internetmediated discourse can, however, amplify local concerns and local online citizen journalists. Elites and activists who are immersed in the controversy naturally have difficulty understanding how the public could remain unaware of their rationales of support or opposition. He is the author of numerous books and articles on political discourse, the mass media and. This paper explores their relation ship by analyzing the discourse on nuclear power in four. Carragee and roefs 2004 already discussed the neglect of power in. Media discourse and public opinion on nuclear power a constructionist approach. Movements and media as interacting systems by william a.
Public discourse, public opinion and private behavior. In this article, some organizing principles and hypothinteract with the news media and the outcomes for both parties. Numerous are the studies looking at media frames and their effects on readers or viewers, but, as carragee and roefs 2004 criticize, a paradox exists in the fact that a large body of research. Discursive narratives about nuclear power in the aftermath of. Social media are relatively new platforms for issue framers to shape the messages about. William anthony gamson born january 27, 1934 is a professor of sociology at boston college, where he is also the codirector of the media research and action project mrap. Media content analysis can be an economical form of data collection, since much media data is available online or, for the academic researcher, through subscription 1 see macnamara 2005 for a discussion of the tensions about whether media analysis is best suited to quantitative or qualitative use. Gamson and modigliani 1989 refer to frames as interpretative packages that give meaning to an issue. Media discourse and public opinion on nuclear power. Movements and media as interacting systems show all authors. Advertising, agendabuilding, agendasetting effects, attention, attribution. It is the core of a larger unit of public discourse, called a package, that also contains various policy posi.
This conceptualization of a cultural stock of frames serves to formulate six additional premises, which guide my theorizing about framing. At the core of this package is a central organizing idea, or frame, for. Pdf framing as a theory of media effects researchgate. Media discourse is part of the process by which individuals construct meaning, and public opinion is part of the process by which journalists.
Ideally, a media system suitable for a democracy ought to provide its readers with some coherent sense of the broader social forces that affect the conditions of their everyday lives. A thematic analysis of online news stories framing democracy in both iraqs goran sabah ghafour. European scientific journal november 20 edition vol. The structural part of the analysis focuses attention on the power and. Pdf media images and the social construction of reality.
18 1017 708 387 1117 878 573 1354 918 168 997 79 714 630 1478 1358 541 369 174 272 121 635 991 190 739 1355 1353 1226 1230 526 871 601 483 990 912 901 516 674 1108 1414 716 1220